I highly recommend the Abu Garcia Revo S
I just started baitcasting this year and this reel was so easy to learn on. I didn't birdnest for literally dozens of trips... not until my lure got caught on a branch behind me and I still tried casting unknowingly, lol. So it pretty much never birdnests unless you do something silly like hit a branch or try throwing something way too light.
Even though it is the lowest end Revo model at $130 it reviews better than most of the expensive ones and many claim it works better and lasts longer.
Even though it goes for $130 at Bass Pro, I got mine as a combo with an All Star Rod for $100 at Dicks. There might be a few floating around, and if there is, they are $75 now for the combo.
Just look at the reviews... Mine is the 3rd review down (towelie).
http://www.basspro.com/Abu-Garcia-Revo&153;-S-LowProfile-Baitcast-Reel/product/84683/-1303266
I highly recommend this abu, over the silver max and over the orra.