Those are some great tips stratos1966 . I was doing great on crankbaits and jerkbaits until 2 weeks ago, and suddenly all I can catch is pickerel. Going out Sat. and Sun. on small ponds and Crystal Lake up in Haverhill.
I've never had any luck with jigs, but after reading some of these and other comments I think I'm fishing them to fast. I have 2 questions about them:
1. Since I assume you primarily fish the bottom with them, Don't you get hung up in muck and create a lousy presentation? Everywhere I've been fishing still has some vegetation and a ton of rotting stuff and leaves on the bottom. I can never be sure at what point during the retrieve I snagged that leaf and feel like I just spent 5 minutes using vegetation as a lure.
2. What colors, weights and trailers would you recommend for a) deep clear water, gravel bottom, and b) shallow, stained water, heavy vegetation.
I throw "football jigs in deeper open water. They are called football jigs because of the shape of their head. I fish them on clean bottoms, usually rocks, gravel or sand. they will be either 1/2oz or 3/4 oz. depending on depth. Over 15 feet I go up to 3/4oz.
Pitching or flipping jigs go "into" things like trees, bushes and docks. They are usually 1/4 oz or 3/8th oz. In weeds you can use grass jigs, they have a pointier cone like head that makes them less weedy. 1/8 oz to 1/4 oz in the weeds. All jigs should be natural colors. Black, black and blue, black and brown, green pumpkin watermelon. I use pork trailers 85% of the time.
Wool gloves are the answer. And the cold really is tolerable, it's the wind that kills.
It's just about time for reaction baits, jerkbaits and super shallow cranks like minus -1. You want to keep moving and cover a ton of water. Fish start to bunch up for winter. When you get 1 spend a little more time trying to trigger another. keep changing up the cadance of (shawn will love this) your jerking..... jerk, pause, jerk jerk pause, jerk LOOOONG pause, jerk jerk LOOONG pause, jerk jerk jerk pause. saem thing with the crankbait. Start with a stright retrieve and then work in pauses. Spped it up, slow it down, bump it into things. When you catch one remember the retriev you were using and duplicate it. Revisit areas where you caught multiple fish. Affter letting them "rest" you can trigger more. Change color and size to trigger more. I will break through thin ice in the am to get out on a pond to do this. Shallow ponds are best because the fish do not have deep water to retreat to and you always have the bait infront of fish.