the rod is probably throwing you off also when u push the spool button does the lure fall fast or slow i generally like my stuff to fall pretty fast but I've been using bait casting gear for 10+ years so its all in the thumb for a beginner id say a rate of fall in between fast and slow. try taking a old 1/2oz to 3/8 oz jig and try that its always easier to cast something with some weight than something thats light hope this helps also i might add my good friend Neil Dootson owns Dark Side Reelz, he's a reel maintenance and repairman per say and i know for a fact he can take your 100$ bps pro qualifier and make it into a 300$+ reel. he does amazing work check him out
www.darksidereelz.com his videos on youtube are insane i guarantee you've never seen reels work like they do after he works his magic hope this helps and pray for the ice to melt!!! tight lines!