Fishing near Sutton in Worcester County, MA

3.57 Rating based on 353 Reviews
  • Most Caught Species: Largemouth Bass, Chain Pickerel, Mirror Carp, Yellow Perch, Bluegill, Smallmouth Bass
  • # of fishing spots within 25 miles: 180
  • # of reports within 25 miles: 1070
  •  
  • Discuss Sutton area fishing in our Massachusetts Fishing Forum

Sutton Fishing Photos

11/6/11 - Singletary Lake near Sutton

11/6/11 - Singletary Lake

1lb Singletary Rainbow slams a KVD Squarebill
Added by: meat7gtk
View Full Size
Crappie near Sutton

Crappie

Added by: bangbang
View Full Size

Top Fishing Spots near Sutton

Singletary Lake
Singletary Lake

Avg. Rating: 4
# Reviews: 1
Views: 9783

Singletary Pond
Singletary Pond

Avg. Rating: 0
# Reviews:
Views: 6299

Ramshorn Lake
Ramshorn Lake

Avg. Rating: 0
# Reviews:
Views: 2707

Manchaug Pond
Manchaug Pond

Avg. Rating: 3
# Reviews: 2
Views: 7434

Fischerville Pond
Fischerville Pond

Avg. Rating: 3
# Reviews: 2
Views: 2304

Whitin Reservoir
Whitin Reservoir

Avg. Rating: 0
# Reviews:
Views: 4024

Sutton Area Fish Species

Recent Sutton Fishing Reports

Bass Tournament Singletary Lake Fishing Report Jun 29, 2009

Bass Tournament Singletary Lake

Singletary Lake, Sutton Ma. -

Start time was 6am, weather was 60 degrees and foggy with a light drizzle. Water temp was 70 degrees. We start off heading across the lake to some b...

Avg. Rating: 4
# Reviews: 3 Views:
Review Report
Created by: iamabasshole
Map It
11/6/11 - Singletary Lake - Millbury, MA Fishing Report Nov 08, 2011

11/6/11 - Singletary Lake - Millbury, MA

Singletary Lake, Millbury, MA -

I reconnected with an old friend Justin I hadnt seen in 10-12 years recently on Facebook. He's has a nice 18-1/2 Skeeter. Our original plan was to...

Avg. Rating: 4
# Reviews: 4 Views:
Review Report
Created by: meat7gtk
Map It
Kyle and I on Singletary Fishing Report Jun 13, 2010

Kyle and I on Singletary

Singletary Lake -

My son Kyle and I got a late start on the water at 7:30, weather conditions cloudy, little wind and an occasional shower. The fishing was good most of...

Avg. Rating: 4
# Reviews: 1 Views:
Review Report
Created by: happyhooker
Map It
A Crappie Day At Singletary Fishing Report Nov 07, 2011

A Crappie Day At Singletary

Lake Singletary, MA -

I went out for a few hours sunday to Lake Singletary. The plan for the day was to hit a couple spots to hopefully get into some smallies. Water temp...

Avg. Rating: 4
# Reviews: 7 Views:
Review Report
Created by: bangbang
Map It
Singletary Lake 6/17/2012 Fishing Report Jun 18, 2012

Singletary Lake 6/17/2012

Singletary Lake -

Fished from 6AM-2PM with my friend Dave. Pulled in over 30 smallies with one being over 2lbs, 4 largemouths biggest being 2 1/2lbs and 2 pickerel...E...

Avg. Rating: 5
# Reviews: 4 Views:
Review Report
Created by: centralmassfish
Map It
8/3/14 - Singletary Shootout Fishing Report Aug 04, 2014

8/3/14 - Singletary Shootout

Singletary Lake, Millbury, MA -

Myself and some of the boys got together for a little shootout at Singletary. 7 boats total on this mostly overcast, but nice day overall (besides the...

Avg. Rating: 5
# Reviews: 8 Views:
Review Report
Created by: meat7gtk
Map It

Baits and Tackle used near Sutton

Check Prices

  • 4 " Senkos black blue flake drop shot and Road Kill Bass Pro style Senko. We tried many different colors and baits but most of our fish came on these two colors.
  • Shiner hooded beside dorsal fin.
  • We used feed corn and Dat food boilies in the flavor strawberry
  • Shiners (big)
  • Senko
    Kivas
    Rubber Frog
  • Dead Bait
  • worms mid shiners and power bait
  • For bait I kept it simple today. I was travelling by canoe and wanted a light bait bucket. Chick peas, and a batch of strawberry chicks plus DAT food boilies. I used a small amount of ground bait made of breadcrumbs and rolled oats plus some crushed boilies and river water to help hold the carp in the area.

  • Molasses maize,
    Dat Food
    Chick peas,
    Fishy Ground Bait
  • Dat food (strawberry, Gold, scopex)
    Pescaviva trout pellet and scopex
    WCB Scopex Pop-ups
    chick peas

Live Bait (Other) Check Prices

  • 1 on the Senko
    1 on Sqiggly tail
    4 on Kivas
  • Hand size Kivas
  • Shiinners
  • Perfect size Kivas
  • Chung's Best
  • Medium sized Frog
  • Medium to small sized frogs seem to work the best but ive even caught pike and largemouth off of a full grown frog sink em or let em swim on top either way works very effectivly
  • Big shiners
  • Big Kiva
  • Chartreuse Powerbait

Creature Check Prices

  • Carolina Rig
  • 2.21lbs, 1-1/4lbs, and 1lb were my 3 fish
  • Creature baits and senkos around docks.
  • More creature baits, around fallen timber and brush.

Tube Check Prices

  • drop shots and topwater
  • Weighted tubes, spoon, and rubber worms
  • Grayish Blue with flakes 1/8weighted hook
  • purple smoke tube
    salt and pepper flake tube
    june bug tube
  • june bug tubes
  • June Bug tube
  • salt and pepper purple flake tube
  • Chartreuse pepper flack tube
  • pumpkin seed tube
  • june bug tube

Minnow Check Prices

  • Shinner Hooked beside Dorsal fin
  • Shinner hooked beside dorsal fin.
  • live bait old school
  • Small
    Medium
    Big Dead Pondies
  • Chung's Best
  • Large minnow with a rattling bobber, size 1 hook
  • large shiners on trokar hooks
  • medeim to large shiners and never thought nightcrawlers would work through the ice but i ended up with a crappie and a perch while jigging one just waitin for my flags
  • 5 Tip Ups- Shiners
  • I found that using medium shiners with a bass hook hooked through the back of the tail worked best. The bait seems to stay much more lively that way.

Topwater Bait Check Prices

  • My only Smallie was on a topwater. 1lber culled out.
  • see Damon for detailz
    Couldn't tell ya -Yoda tied everything up this day
  • Frog themed Hedon mini torpedo
  • Jitterbug
  • Jitter Bug
  • Zmkanpop frog elite w/ chart belly rigged w/ a 4/0 Gami
  • Skitter Pop
    Black size 8 Wooly Bugger
  • Zara Spook Baby Bass
  • Rebel Popper - Perch
  • Black jitter bug.

Lizard Check Prices

  • watermelon/red jr brush hog w/slider head 1/8 oz
  • 6 inch Zoom watermelon rigged mini carolina w/ 1/4 oz tube weight
  • 8" Pumpkinseed

Jerk Bait Check Prices

  • 4.5in Slug-go - Arkansas Shad
  • bullet weights are my favorite. punch right into the lilly pads or vegetation laying down in front of you.
  • 4.5in Slug-go
  • 4.5in Slug-go(Wacky Rigged) - Arkansas Shad
  • Sluggo
  • I've used Rapalas and Carolina-rigged rubber worms, but Yamamotos easily outfished them 2:! in this pond and the surrounding
  • 4.5in Slug-go - Tennessee Shad
  • BASS ASASSIONS WHITE,BABY BASS AND ARKANSAW SHINNER WORK WELL!
  • 4.5in Slug-go - Tennessee Shad
  • 4.5in Slug-go - Rainbow Trout

Fly (Other) Check Prices

  • Again Dat food( shrimplies and gold) and feed corn were present. We also tried a packbait of Limeycarper, as well as bread, strawberry canned corn, and luncheon meat.

Spinnerbait / Buzzbait Check Prices

  • My 3 Fish Limit was:
    1lb 11oz
    1lb 4oz
    14oz

    4 Shorts too
  • Fast retrieve
  • 2lber on Spinnerbait
    10" on drop shot
  • Spinnerbait/Chatterbait
    11-1/2" Short
    1lber culled
    Limit was:
    1-1/2lbs
    1lb 7oz
    1-1/4lbs
    1lb 1oz
    1lber
  • Chartreuse and white Z-Man Chatter Bait
  • Chartreuse and white Z-man chatter bait
  • Spinner white/green...silver/gold blades
  • Brown/Gold w/ Red
  • brown/gold w/ red
  • Stirke King KVD Sexy Shad Spinnerbait

Frog Bait Check Prices

  • Zman leoprd frog pattern rigged w/ 6/0 Gami hook
  • Koppers live target in bull frog and toad
  • Frogs, Jigs and texas rigged creatures did the damage
  • Spro Frog
  • 11" Bass in Senko at Dudley
    1lber on Frog at Heard

Streamer Check Prices

  • Chart/White clouser

Stick Bait Check Prices

  • Black Huskie Jerk and black and blue football jig
  • Jerkbait
  • All morning chain pickerel were hitting my plastic lures, but not taking any hooks. One did manage to bite my power worm in just the right spot however, and gave a nice fight. After that I threw a newly acquired Rapala Husky Jerk around, and got an even nicer pickerel in return! If anyone wants that lure, it's still there, stuck in a tree branch.
  • X-Rap
  • Jerkbait
    1st was 13in 1lb
    2nd was 12in 11oz
    3rd was 11.5in 10oz
  • Jerk Bait
  • Jerk Bait
    1st Calico was 8in
    2nd was 10in
    3rd was 9in
  • Rapala, golden, 4" sinking

In-Line Spinner Check Prices

  • 11-3/4" on a tube
    11-1/2" on wacky worm
    7" and 10" on inline spinner
  • 6" and 8" on inline spinner
  • firetiger mepps aglia with a red treble hook and custom feather teaser tied on by yours truly
  • 1/6oz Rooster Tail - Brown Metallic
  • 1/8in Rooster Tail
  • Rooster Tail
    1. 15.5in
    2. 13in 1lb
  • 1/8 Rooster Tail
  • 1/8oz Rooster Tail
  • 1st. 8in 6oz
    2nd. 5in
  • Rooster Tail
    1. 9in
    2. 10.5in

Dry Fly Check Prices

Worm Check Prices

  • 5" rattlesnake, red
  • 5" senko
  • short plastic worm, slow pull/fall/sit retrieve
  • Senko
  • using a salt shaker worm on a jig head. 6 fish were bass.
    My son caught a pickerel when he was cranking the worm through the water.
  • Shakeyhead - 1-1/2lber, and 1-1/4ber
  • Shakey Head
  • 4in Senko
  • Shakey Head
    Both Smallies were 1lb
  • 4in Senko - These were the other three of my limit:
    3rd - 17in 2lb 1oz
    4th and 5th 13in 1lb'ers

Plastic Swimbait Check Prices

  • BkBl Senko Rigged Wacky
  • Senkos Black with Flakes

    Kivas the little pretty ones
    hahahahahah
  • Dark Senkos wacky
  • Powerbait 7" plastic worms
  • Dark Powerbait 7" worms. no weight.
  • xps swimbait

Hard Baits Check Prices

  • 1lb 10oz was the only one to make the limit.

    1lb 6oz, 1-1/4lber culled out

    a couple other 1-1/4lb to 1lbers, and some shorts
  • Jerkbait

Soft Baits Check Prices

  • 1lb 13oz and 1-1/4lbs
  • 2-1/4lber was my best
    Bunch 1lbers, and shorts
  • Tourney Lunker at 4.34lbs
    The rest were 3/4lbs or smaller
  • 1-1/4lber & 3/4lb in the limit
    the rest were 3/4lbs and smaller
  • All between 3/4lb and 1-1/4lbs
  • 1-1/4lber was my best
    bunch of 1lbers and shorts
  • They hit everything! Jigs, Spinnerbait, Senko, Spider Grub, Crankbaits
  • Spider Grubs, Crankbait, Jig, Senko, Spinnerbait.
    A couple at 11-1/2", most between 10"-11"
  • Dropshot
  • Drop shot

Roundhead Jig Check Prices

  • 1/16 oz leadhead w/3" rainbow trout sluggo
  • 1/16#Sluggo leadhead with 3"chartreuse/pepper Kalin grub
  • 3" sluggo 1/16 oz #4 hook unpainted BPS leadhead Caught all fish on black and gold flake
  • 5" Kalin grub Rootbeer flake 1/8oz 2/0 leadhead
  • first bass caught on a jig as i haven't used them much. spent the day practicing working at it.

Lure (Other) Check Prices

  • Rooster tail
  • Small rooster tails and spinner baits tend to work well here. I like reds and browns some greens.
  • Again rooster tails work well as an all around bait, small spinners etc.
  • Spinners and rooster tails, fly spinners work well for the pan fish as well
  • Again same as listed rooster tails, spinners etc.
  • 4" black slider worm w/1/8 oz head
  • Rocket Shad Spinner Bait
  • Rooster Tail
  • DARK GREEN SHAKY HEAD WORM ON BALL HEAD JIG
  • 1 on Rooster Tail
    1 on Rapala RTR5 Rattlin'/Suspending

Craw Check Prices

  • yamamoto watermelon crawdad
  • doesn't look it in the pic, but he was 15 inches.
  • nihcolas got 3 on a perch rapala. i got 4 on a crawdad.
  • crawdads and soft frogs
  • brownish red 3-1/4 inch yamamoto crawdad

Hard Swimbait Check Prices

  • Shad Rap in Blue/Black color
  • If your going for Larry, you should use a large swimmer bait that only he will hit
  • First cast and I had one.

Jigs Check Prices

  • Spider Grub
    1st was 2-1/2lbs
    2nd was 1lb 6oz
  • surface plug. almost as big as the 2 bass caught. must be the spawning ground. ballsy little buggars...
  • jig n pig
  • Our Limit was :
    My 3.26lbs, 3lber, 1lb 6oz, 1lb 2oz, and Chucks 1lb 5oz

    1lb and under on the rest
  • 11" on Shaky Head
    15-1/2in 1lb 9oz on Jig

Crankbait Check Prices

  • 3 in the 3/4lb to 1lb range in about 10 minutes
  • Wally Marshall Crappy Crank Bait with blood hooks
  • Squarebill, and dropshot
  • Rapala Jointed crankbait
  • crankbaits and spinners
  • perch rapala
  • perch rapala - was surprised to get nothing on a soft worm.
  • rapal
  • rapala
  • KVD Rattling Square Bill

Bass Jig Check Prices

  • Blk/red w blk mister twister trailer
  • 1-1/2lber on Jig
    11" on Dropshot
  • All Between 18"-22" on Jig, and drop shot
  • green pumpkin jigs 1/8 oz to 3/4oz
  • black and blue, with a blue craw trailer
  • All on a swimjig

    My 9.75lb Limit was:
    2lbs 11oz
    2lbs 2oz
    2lbs 1oz
    1lb 8oz
    1lb 6oz

    5 more in the 1-1/4lb to 3/4lb range
  • 4-1/4lb on a jig
    3-3/4lb and 1lb 15oz on senko
    two 1lbers on buzzbait
  • !/4 oz bk bl jig wYamamoto trailer bro Joe used 5" senko wacky Gr / wh
  • black and blue round head jig with a berkley dark green traler.
  • brown

Emerger Check Prices

  • Spinner bait - strike king

Soft Swimbait Check Prices

  • 4"senko
  • texas rigged senko
  • 4" dacquiri senko rigged texas on 3/0 Gammi
  • 6" berkley havoc sick fish clear natural bream color and painted with garlic cented chartreuse dip n glo to resemble yellow perch.
  • bk bl 5" senko texas rigged
  • Plain white Swim bait Plastic.
  • Frog = 1 lil bump
    White Shad = 2 LMB
  • Reaction Innovations Soft swimbait
  • 4" senkos texas rigged in Bk/Bl and watermellon red
  • Reaction Innovations
    Little Dipper
    Dirty Sanchez

Wet Fly Check Prices

  • White wooly bugger
  • White Wooly bugger

Casting & Trolling Spoon;22 Check Prices

  • silver spoon
  • Up on the more northern end of things, we hooked into a few Landlocked salmon bites. Mostly smaller guys, but a few just keepers. Dad hit them on a variety of lures, but all mine came in on Little Cleo spoons. Another species crossed off the bucket list!

Nightcrawler Check Prices

  • just a small piece
  • Nightcrawlers and troutworms
  • nightcrawlers with an eagle claw hook rig with gold spinner "keep a nice long worm tail hanging from the hook"
  • Just had the crawler on the bottem. Had the hook about 1 foot above the sinker, so the sinker got the weeds instead of the hook.
  • we used live worms it worked very well
  • night crawlers are now my favorite live bait.
  • night crawlers and worms get the fish bitting.
  • nice large nightcrawlers
  • 10-12 hook, half way threaded, dark part of the night crawler

Lipless Bait Check Prices

  • Live Target Golden Shiner Vibration Trap Lipless Crankbait
  • 1/2oz Rapala Rattlin'
  • rattler
  • we both used rattlers all night. first time we have used them for a good length of time and tonight they were working.
  • Greyish, green, red face

Grub Check Prices

  • Pink with blue flake Kalin Grub Texas rigged
  • Pumpkin tail carolina style
  • Yellow Grubs from Walmart with Brown weighted jig heads. Also caught one on a purple ribbontail on a Texas rig.
  • 20 in the 6"-8" range were relentless all day!
  • Dropshotting

Live Baits Check Prices

  • white rooster tail

Panfish Jig Check Prices

  • Bright yellow, fuzzy and small.

Other Check Prices

  • Inline Spinner, Dropshot
    one 6" and 4 other between 10" ans 11" Smallies
  • Big
    Dead
    Golden's
  • Again corn, white bread work well..I make much of my own dough bait or order some mixes through Wacker Baits
  • scented maize and corn
  • Many things keep coming along for the ride. Sweet corn flavored various ways,
    Feed corn heavy on molasses,
    Dat food milk based with heavy seed/forage
  • Dat food, feed corn were used. Dat food produced some but the real hitter of the day was a grits based pack bait ( see the bait tutorial in the forums or on www.blackstonecarp.com)
  • Same as the other locations. Maple peas worked well for me here, corn, bread, boilies of various flavors.
  • Feed corn and Dat food boilies have become my baits of choice as well as staples in any trip.

    Molasses and fishy flavors seem to still work well, though strawberry has been more and more effective.

  • Feed corn is a staple for our trips lately, though it was clearly out performed number wise by a cat food/grits/cream corn mix method-pack bait.

    The biggest fish of the session however was taken along the far left margins, with 2 pieces of feed corn on a sliding hair rig, with a size 6 hook.
  • Sweet corn

Stay Updated

Sign up for our weekly newsletter to stay updated on Sutton fishing and other Massachusetts fishing. You'll also receive community updates, invites to try new features and promotions from our partners.

MA Fish Finder

Social Links