Haha awesome!
Yeah it is really tough to color these, I've tried, trust me. However carp have really good eye sight, and a very keen sense of smell/taste. That said they should be able to find your small brown bait even if the water was entirely murky. Did you notice if they were feeding at all? Like sniffing through the leaves etc or were they just kinda hanging out cruising near the top?
If they were just cruising, especially lately they could have just been basking in the heat and not been feeding much. You can get them more interested by chumming a few free boilies out there, or some sweet corn...by getting them feeding confidently around your hook, it just becomes a matter of time before..zzzzzzzzzz! This isn't an end all be all..weather and such play a big part in what they are doing, but it is a good general tactic. For a new water I would send a handful of boilies or corn out, then toss my hook into the same spot. This will usually get you into something, though it may still take time.
What ponds in Methuen? Maybe We can get together sometime soon and hit em up and see if we can't get em going. Share a few things as well.
Posted Tue Aug 02, 2011 7:19 pm