Hey every kind of idiotic question but is it a pain in the ass to use a baitcaster from a canoe I use mine in the boat all the time just think it will be hard to get hook set and what not
Spinning gear is fine for light tackle up to 1/4 oz and great for skipping brush and docks, if you want to throw crankbaits and spinnerbaits I would use the baitcast reel.
You should be fine with jigs if you use a fine wire hooks and make sure you sharpen them.
Many of the kayakers here use baitcasters. I use them almost exclusively. It is true that it is harder to "cross their eyes" from a canoe or kayak due to low angle, less leverage but spinning gear has the same problem, so you do your best. I'm convinced that I lose more good fish from the yak than someone fishing from a boat simply because I can't always get a good hookset (e.g. I try to set the hook hard and the kayak slides toward the fish).
I had same luck a couple of weeks ago three of us out we caught 1 small striper and 1 sea bass. The sea bass was about 5 lbs.
The guy we went out with has a lobster permit and has 6 traps we pulled in 10 lobster which at least made for a great feast...